Compare the Top Card Grading Companies
When it comes to grading sports cards, Pokémon, or other trading cards, the company you choose can make a huge difference in both value and credibility. PSA, Beckett, CGC, and TAG are among the most popular grading services in the collectibles market — but each has its own strengths, pricing, and specialties.
This grading comparison chart breaks down their differences in cost, turnaround time, slab design, and resale reputation so you can make the best choice for your collection. Whether you’re submitting vintage cards, TCGs, or modern hits, this guide helps you compare everything side by side.
Grading Comparison Chart — PSA · Beckett (BGS) · CGC · TAG
Compare grading companies side-by-side to find the best choice for your collectibles based on price, turnaround, and credibility.
| Feature | PSA | Beckett (BGS) | CGC | Tag |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Starting Cost | $27.99 (bulk) | $14.95 (bulk) | $14 (bulk) | $20 (budget) |
| Turnaround | 45 days | 45+ days | 50 days | 30 days |
| Subgrades | No | No | No | Yes |
| Population Report | Comprehensive | Detailed | Active | Limited/New |
| Best for | Vintage & High-Value | Condition Collectors | TCG Collectors | Budget / Quick Flips |
| Verification | QR + Cert # | QR + Cert # | QR + Cert # | App / QR |
| Resale Credibility | Highest | High | Growing | Emerging |
PSA — Industry Standard
Most recognized grading service with highest resale values, ideal for serious collectors and investors.
Beckett (BGS) — Subgrade Detail
Popular with modern card collectors who value subgrades and premium label aesthetics.
CGC — TCG & Fast
Preferred for Pokémon, Magic, and TCGs with quick turnaround and fair pricing.
TAG — Affordable & Modern
Tech-driven newcomer offering quick, budget-friendly grading with digital transparency and QR-based verification.
Which Should You Choose?
- For resale value: PSA
- For detailed subgrades: Beckett
- For TCG collectors: CGC
- For fast, affordable tech-driven grading: TAG
Use this chart as a guide — research submission promos and population reports before sending cards for grading.
FAQ – Collectible Grading Comparison
Q1: Which grading company increases card value the most?
A: PSA is generally considered the gold standard for increasing resale value, especially for vintage sports cards and high-end collectibles.
Q2: Is Beckett better than PSA?
A: Beckett (BGS) provides more detailed subgrades and a thicker slab, making it great for condition-focused collectors. However, PSA still leads in overall market recognition and resale prices.
Q3: What grading service is best for Pokémon and TCG cards?
A: CGC has become a popular choice among TCG collectors due to its fair grading, modern label design, and quick turnaround.
Q4: Is TAG a legitimate grading company?
A: TAG is a newer grading option that focuses on affordability and fast, app-based verification. It’s a solid choice for budget-friendly or quick submissions.
Q5: How do I decide which service to use?
A: Choose PSA for long-term value, Beckett for detailed grades, CGC for TCG cards, and TAG for fast, affordable grading.